I don’t live in the middle of nowhere, but I can see it from my house.
My home is located about an hour north of downtown Minneapolis, and to put it simply, we built out in farm country. The nearest spot on the map is Dalbo, MN, a couple of miles away. We are rural, and while we enjoy the benefits of quiet country living and ample space, we lack certain modern conveniences of city living, such as cable TV and DSL Internet service.
We tried WildBlue satellite Internet. The latency of the speed of light made it unusable for even basic web surfing, such as booking airline tickets. When I woke up one Saturday morning a year ago and found that my iPhone suddenly had 4 bars of 3G, not EDGE, signal on AT&T, I ran to the nearest AT&T store and picked up a USB data stick.
It’s fast.
The problem with AT&T is that they are very conservative with their data plans. $60/month gets you a maximum 5 GB of combined uploaded and downloaded data bytes, and they charge $0.05 per MB after that. Those of you quick with the multiplication skills already picked up on the fact that this equates to more than $50 per GB in overage charges. Outrageous.
On the other hand, Verizon also claims to offer 3G speed in my area. Two weeks ago, when I exhausted my 5 GB allowance from AT&T before I was done working at home for the month, I went and picked up a 3G hotspot device (the FiveSpot) from Verizon, which also functions as a USB modem. Verizon charges $80 for a 10 GB allowance, with only $10 per GB in excess of the allowance. Quite reasonable in a $/GB comparison.
But how do they compare speedwise? Not very well, I am afraid.
| Provider |
Download Speed
Mbits/sec |
Upload Speed
Mbits/sec |
Monthly
Charge |
Overage
Charge |
| AT&T |
3.7 |
1.4 |
$60 for 5 GB |
$50 per GB |
| Verizon |
0.93 |
0.62 |
$80 for 10 GB |
$10 per GB |
Yin and Yang. AT&T is significantly faster, usually by a factor of three, sometimes five times faster. In fact, on a good day, I can get sustained 5 to 7 Mbits per second true download speeds from AT&T. On occasion, I have briefly exceeded 1 Mbit/sec on my Verizon device (in USB modem mode.) But Verizon costs less per GB, and seems to be more reliable. When I use the Verizon connection for VPN and Remote Desktop to work for my clients from home, I rarely have issues. I seem to get booted off a couple times per hour when using VPN via AT&T. Hmmm. Might they be trying to discourage this kind use of their network?
I love the AT&T speed. Technically, I’m getting speeds in excess of the new “4G” networks advertised by other carriers with my AT&T USB Mercury DataConnect device, which is 3G. Sadly, 5 GB per month is just too little, even when I try to carefully ration bandwidth.
So, as a businessman who relies on Internet service to be billable, my company pays for both. Besides, anyone who knows me also knows how much I appreciate redundancy.